Flash websites – pros and cons

by Lee Hopkins on August 25, 2006 · 4 comments

in Uncategorized

Flash My exceptionally learned colleague Dan York recently pointed out that building your site in Flash, whilst good for interactivity, makes it very difficult to ‘word-of-mouth’ your site with a tasty image.

After all, capturing a logo or something to use as a visual cue is impossible if the site is all Flash. It was a blogged plea from Dan that started me adding images to my blog posts all those years ago…

Like Dan, I have been telling clients for years to stay away from Flash because of its poor search engine optimisation properties – plus its well nigh impossible to link to a specific ‘page’ in a Flash sequence [I say "well nigh impossible" because I've never heard of anyone able to do it, but if I just said "impossible" there would no doubt be some clever clogs who would come along and make me look like a Luddite].

It turns out that search engine optimisation is getting better at reading Flash filesgood news!

And it turns out there may be other reasons why you might want to consider building your site in Flash…

  • It’s much harder to comment spam a Flash form
  • It’s much harder for naughty people to steal your images, music, logos etc and put them to a use you never intended
  • It’s much easier to protect your IP (Intellectual Property).

Sure, all of the above can be done to a Flash .swf file, but you have to be a really clever clogs to do it — like Kazama obviously is.

Thanks for the conversation on your blog, Dan — it benefits us all.


Technorati : , ,

  • http://www.toddand.com/ Todd And

    I’m definitely not a fan of 100 percent Flash sites. I prefer hybrid, integrating Flash and HTML. Here are two of the biggest reasons MKTG executives want to stay away from all Flash:

    1) Poor ability to measure. Microsites and directories for measuring marketing campaigns are very difficult in all Flash. If I’m executing a direct marketing campaign asking people to click a certain page, or if I’m running ad campaigns and want to send people to a specific page on my site (i.e., http://www.mysite.com/adtest), I won’t be able to with an all Flash site. And, therefore, I won’t be able to measure the results of the campaign.

    2) No use of the browser back button. When you navigate Flash sites and try to click the back button on the browser, you go to the whole previous site you were visiting, not the previous page of the current site you’re at. For many, this can be a major annoyance. As a marketer, I don’t like the fact that visitors can’t easily backtrack.

  • http://www.toddand.com Todd And

    I’m definitely not a fan of 100 percent Flash sites. I prefer hybrid, integrating Flash and HTML. Here are two of the biggest reasons MKTG executives want to stay away from all Flash:

    1) Poor ability to measure. Microsites and directories for measuring marketing campaigns are very difficult in all Flash. If I’m executing a direct marketing campaign asking people to click a certain page, or if I’m running ad campaigns and want to send people to a specific page on my site (i.e., http://www.mysite.com/adtest), I won’t be able to with an all Flash site. And, therefore, I won’t be able to measure the results of the campaign.

    2) No use of the browser back button. When you navigate Flash sites and try to click the back button on the browser, you go to the whole previous site you were visiting, not the previous page of the current site you’re at. For many, this can be a major annoyance. As a marketer, I don’t like the fact that visitors can’t easily backtrack.

  • http://www.geocities.com/claren44/radio Clarence Jones

    It’s not too hard to get Flash Video (.flv) files to a hard drive. Use Firefox & install one of a couple of extentions made for the purpose. They’ll download the stuff in a heartbeat (or so I’ve heard…not that I would do such a thing lol).
    Flash sites have gotten Old. I get really antsy when ‘loading…’ comes on my screen.
    Love & Peace, Clarence

  • http://www.geocities.com/claren44/radio Clarence Jones

    It’s not too hard to get Flash Video (.flv) files to a hard drive. Use Firefox & install one of a couple of extentions made for the purpose. They’ll download the stuff in a heartbeat (or so I’ve heard…not that I would do such a thing lol).
    Flash sites have gotten Old. I get really antsy when ‘loading…’ comes on my screen.
    Love & Peace, Clarence

Previous post:

Next post: